Wednesday, November 21, 2012

THE PHILOSOPHY GIRLS EXPLAIN CATO

Hello, Theory Cornerites! My name's Dandelion Fortesque, and I'm a Philosophy Girl. As you probably know, each Philosophy Girl specializes in a particular niche in the history of philosophy. Mine is the Roman Stoics...you know: Marcus Aurelius, Seneca...people like that. 


Today I'll be talking about Cato the Younger, the great Roman Stoic and Senator who disemboweled himself when Julius Caesar took power. Cato wasn't the type to commit suicide. He did it because he knew that Caesar would have him killed anyway, and he wanted to die in a manner that would inspire people to unseat the tyrant and restore The Republic. 


 It's worth asking, "Why did Cato believe that his death would motivate anybody to do anything?" After all, his adversary Caesar was popular and had convinced a lot of people that what the nation needed was a benevolent dictatorship.

  
The answer to that question is an interesting one. Most of the higher-ups in Rome were 
associated with the interests of the various ruling families or political factions. In the Senate only Cato and a small number of others had real moral authority. When he took a stand and backed it up with his life, people listened. 


That's because Cato had a reputation for objectivity and for thinking things through for himself. It was well known that he wanted to do what was best for Rome, regardless of his own biases, and regardless of what special interests thought. Every Senator claimed to do the same thing, but it only a small number actually did. How did Cato manage to convince a bunch of cynical aristocrats that he was the real deal?


Well, he lived the way that he spoke. He wore a simple black toga when all his peers wore lavish purple. He lived in a modest house and walked to work. He ate what the common people ate. When he was a general, he disdained a horse and walked along with the soldiers. He ate what his soldiers ate, and slept in the same gear. When sick, he never complained.

People are impressed by self-discipline. 


Cato's often cited by people who believe in the importance of character. He wasn't the richest or the highest born Roman, or the most successful general, and yet he was as influential as any of them. You could say that his character was worth an entire legion. 


That's really all I have to say, but I can't resist adding a footnote. Here's how Plutarch described Cato's death. Don't read it if you're squeamish...it's pretty grizzly:

Cato did not immediately die of the wound; but struggling, fell off the bed, and throwing down a little mathematical table that stood by, made such a noise that the servants, hearing it, cried out. And immediately his son and all his friends came into the chamber, where, seeing him lie weltering in his own blood, great part of his bowels out of his body, but himself still alive and able to look at them, they all stood in horror. The physician went to him, and would have put in his bowels, which were not pierced, and sewed up the wound; but Cato, recovering himself, and understanding the intention, thrust away the physician, plucked out his own bowels, and tearing open the wound, immediately expired.


I warned 'ya! See you next time!

6 comments:

Unknown said...

Inspiring! My Latin classes never really got into Cato. Are there any books you'd recommend?

Eddie Fitzgerald said...

Roberto: There's lots of good books on Rome, but most are out of print. It helps if you live near a good university library. Just peruse the titles and read whatever takes your fancy.

It also helps if you can afford to rent unabridged audio books on the subject. Blackstone Audio used to have a good selection.

Their ads emphasized the same mass market titles that other companies carried, but their catalogue used to have lots of classical readings. With Blackstone you could listen to Gibbon's "Fall of the Roman Empire" in the car!

I started reading about Rome by reading fun stuff about battles and the antics of crazy emperors. After a while you get seduced by the more serious books.

I especially liked Liddel Hart's book on Scipio Africanus, and another book comparing Demosthenes' "On the Crown" speech with Cicero's "Against Cataline." I also liked the history of the early republic by Polybius. Caesar's Commentaries are a good read. The book everybody likes is Plutarch's "Lives," but I was never able to find a good translation.

If you can get hold of Orson Welles' one hour radio abridgement of Shakespeare's "Julius Caesar" then you'll fall in love with Shakespeare's version of Roman Rhetoric. There's an unabridged stage version of this play, also by Welles, and this is a waste of money, something to be avoided like the plague.


Eddie Fitzgerald said...

Roberto: I looked up Welles' radio version of Julius Caesar on Amazon, and was only able to find an mp3 version for 9 bucks. If I remember right, it's called "Julius Caesar: September 11, 1938", and it's part of a vintage radio series. The length is one hour and 6 minutes.

Don't feel obligated to buy it. I just wanted to be sure that I didn't prompt anyone to buy an infinitely inferior, wretched version that's also marketed as a Welles version of that play.

I forgot to see if itunes has it.

DonB said...

Spotify has the Orson Welles and Mercury Theatre version of Julius Caesar, and its free! Connect to www.spotify.com and click "Get Spotify" on top to download the software.

Title is "Rehearsals - Julius Caesar - September 11, 1938" and runs for 66:38, as mentioned by Eddie.

RSA Certificate said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Eddie Fitzgerald said...

Don: Wow! Thanks a million for the info!!!! I never heard of Spotify before you mentioned it!